Leadership Without Soul is Just Control in Disguise

Let’s start with something that might make you a little uncomfortable (psychologist move, I know):

What if the biggest crisis in leadership today isn’t burnout, bandwidth, or broken systems…
but a lack of love?

The kind of love that shows up as presence, dignity, compassion, and fierce belief in people.
The kind that breathes life back into the places where we spend most of our waking hours.
The kind that revives what I call the soul of leadership—and the soul of work itself.

Why Is Soulful Leadership So Challenging?

Because it’s countercultural.
Most leadership systems reward control, detachment, and deliverables. Soulful leadership invites:

Slowness in a hustle-obsessed landscape
Transparency in hyper-protective, driven spaces
Courage to protect people over optics
Presence over performance

It also requires inner work that isn’t always celebrated—or seen.

So what does soulful leadership look like, practically?

I’ve seen it firsthand via :

A CEO who canceled a project launch to protect the team’s well-being
A VP initiated a 1:1 conversation after a team member’s vulnerable “this isn’t working for me” in a meeting
A healthcare leader who pauses a huddle to acknowledge grief after the loss of a patient
A founder who invites anonymous feedback on their leadership style-and listens
A director who starts every 1:1 with a “life check in” before diving into KPI’s

Psychologist Dr. Ed Deci’s Self-Determination Theory (2000) gives us more clues for soulful leadership. Humans thrive when three core needs are met:

Autonomy – “I have choice.”
Competence – “I have value.”
Relatedness – “I belong here.”

When organizations scale without protecting these needs, people don’t just disengage—they go hollow.
Metrics rise. Humanity withers.
And no one can quite explain why everything feels… empty.

It’s not just a performance issue.
It’s a soul issue.

Want to Lead with Soul This Week? Start Here.

Try one of these micro-practices to bring love (yes, love) back into your leadership:

The 90-Second Love Check
Before your next decision or conversation, pause and ask:
“Am I leading with care—or control?”

The Soul Audit
Scan your week.
What drained you? What brought your team to life?
Reclaim one soul-giving practice for the days ahead.

The Micro-Moment of Meaning
Start one meeting with this question:
“What gave you joy this week?”
(Trust me—this one question can do more for culture than most strategic initiatives ever will.)

The Power of And

You don’t have to choose between growth and humanity.
You can scale with systems that breathe and...
You can lead from both metrics and meaning
You can build culture without losing soul.

By the way, I write more about personalizing leader soul in my new book:
Leading Becomes You: How to Lead from Your Own Skin

Because scaling only works when it doesn’t cost you who you are.

Dr. Natalie Pickering
Organizational Psychologist | Identity-Based Leadership Coach
Author of Leading Becomes You: How to Lead from Your Own Skin
Helping leaders trade performance for presence and create cultures of trust.

Works Cited

Deci, E. L., & Ryan, R. M. (2000). Self-determination theory and the facilitation of intrinsic motivation, social development, and well-being. American Psychologist, 55(1), 68-78.

AI Meets Human Coherence: Why Identity-First Leadership Is the New Competitive Edge

We’ve crossed the AI threshold. Now the question is: who are you on the other side? AI is here and it’s woven into workflows, decisions, customer experiences, performance reviews, and knowledge work. Tasks once considered “strategic” have been automated. Judgment we once thought uniquely human is simulated with startling accuracy. In this moment, leaders are ... Read more

The Shared Work of Engagement: What Leaders Control- and What They Don’t

Every leader I know, whether in a five-person business or a 400,000 multi-site employee system, feels the pressure to “drive engagement.” In a small business, that pressure feels personal—every person matters, every attitude shapes the atmosphere.In a large organization, it comes from dashboards, survey scores, and top-down goals. It’s a noble goal, an important goal—and ... Read more

When Your Greatest Strengths Get Hijacked by Stress (And What to Do About It)

We often think of our strengths as the best parts of us—the qualities that help us succeed, lead, and connect. And they are! But here’s a leadership truth that often goes unspoken: under stress, those very strengths can become our biggest liabilities. This doesn’t mean our strengths vanish. They don’t. But stress hijacks them, puts ... Read more

Clearing Moral Debris: What Leaders Need to Know About Moral Injury

In Leading Becomes You, I write about the emotional and psychological debris leaders accumulate — unresolved experiences, compromises, betrayals, and unprocessed wounds that clog the inner terrain of their leadership. One of the most significant kinds of debris is what psychologists now call moral injury, the disruption to one’s moral fiber that arises from committing ... Read more

Leader Identity Clarity: The Antidote to Leading on Autopilot

Most leaders don’t wake up and say, “Today I’ll lead on autopilot.”But if we’re honest, many of us slip into it without realizing: back-to-back meetings, urgent churn through emails, cuaght up in constant change. We keep moving, but not necessarily with awareness. Autopilot leadership feels safe and necessary—it keeps the wheels turning. But over time, ... Read more

The 3 Things Every Leader Wants — and Why Identity Clarity is the Key to Getting Them

If you ask most leaders what they want, the answers are surprisingly consistent: These are the three non-negotiables of modern leadership. And yet, despite countless trainings, strategies, and “proven” tools, too many leaders are watching these priorities continue to dwindle and decline. Why? Because they’re trying to fix the symptoms instead of the root. The Real Issue ... Read more

Why Leadership Behaviors Don’t Stick Without Identity

You’ve seen it before: A leader goes through a training. They learn how to motivate the team, engage a crucial conversation, delegate, hold one-on-ones, or communicate more clearly. For a few weeks, they try out their new skills. But soon old patterns creep back in. Or worse, the “new behaviors” vanish under pressure. Why? Because ... Read more