From Overperformance to Impact: Leading Without Proving Yourself

Pexels jens johnsson 14223 66100

For many women in leadership, there’s an unspoken pressure to overperform just to prove we belong. Maybe you’ve felt it—the need to work twice as hard, say yes to everything, or produce flawless results just to be seen as credible. It’s exhausting.

But here’s the truth: Leadership isn’t about doing more. It’s about creating impact.

And another truth: Women in leadership tend to score higher on leadership competencies like taking initiative, resilience, and driving results, often adopting a more transformational leadership style.

When we shift from overperformance to intentional leadership, we gain confidence, clarity, and—most importantly—the ability to lead sustainably. Here are five research-backed strategies straight from psychology to inspire you to let go of the need to prove yourself and start leading from a place of strength and authenticity—your own!

Focus on Impact, Not Perfection

The goal-setting research of Locke & Latham (2002) shows that leaders perform best when they focus on clear, meaningful goals—not overwork. Yet, high-achieving women often fall into the trap of doing more instead of doing what matters most.

Strategies:

  • Define what success looks like before diving into a task.
  • Differentiate between mission-critical work vs. perfectionist tendencies—not everything needs to be a masterpiece.
  • Set realistic expectations for yourself and your team.

Separate Your Self-Worth from Your Workload

Self-determination theory (Deci & Ryan, 1985) tells us that people thrive when their motivation is based on purpose and autonomy—not external approval. But when you feel pressure to prove yourself, it’s easy to tie your value to how much you accomplish.

Strategies:

  • Ask yourself: Am I working toward my purpose, or just checking other people’s boxes?
  • Reframe your mindset from “I need to prove myself”“I add value by leading effectively.”
  • Measure success based on progress, impact, and learning, not just sheer effort.

Own Your Achievements (Without Overcompensating)

Research (Exley & Kessler, 2019) shows that women tend to downplay their accomplishments, often fearing they’ll seem arrogant. But let’s be clear: Visibility isn’t vanity—it’s leadership.

Strategies:

  • Track your wins. Keep a simple list of key achievements, challenges overcome, and measurable results.
  • Reframe self-promotion. Instead of thinking, “I don’t want to brag,” try: “I’m advocating for the value I bring.”
  • Practice confident communication. Share your impact with facts, clarity, and without apology.

Say “No” and Check the Illegitimate Guilt

According to Amy Edmondson’s research on psychological safety (1999), the best leaders foster environments where people can set boundaries without fear of judgment. But women in leadership are often expected to take on more, accommodate everyone, and never drop the ball—even when it’s unsustainable.

Strategies:

  • Say no with confidence: “I’d love to help, but I need to stay focused on my current priorities. Let’s find another solution.”
  • Model boundary-setting for your team. When leaders set healthy limits, they give others permission to do the same. This is culture transformation!
  • Reframe “no” as a strategic decision.

Lead Authentically, Not Flawlessly

Brené Brown’s research (2018) shows that leaders who embrace authenticity, not perfection, build stronger teams. Perfectionism can lead to overwork, stress, and disconnection, while vulnerability fosters trust and influence.

Strategies:

  • Focus on leading with clarity of your own purpose, not proving yourself through overwork.
  • When you make a mistake, own it, learn from it, and move forward—without spiraling into self-doubt.
  • Remember: People follow real, relatable leaders—not those trying (impossibly) to appear perfect.

Final Thoughts

The glass ceiling is real, and so is the pressure to overperform. If you’ve ever felt like you need to work harder just to prove yourself, you’re not alone.

But real leadership isn’t about proving—it’s about leading with impact. Your circle of influence sees all that you are doing—lead for them, not for external validation.

Newsletter

Related Posts

Discovering Your Natural Leadership Style

Discovering Your Natural Leadership Style

Understanding your natural leadership style is a crucial step in becoming an effective and authentic leader. When you lead in a way that aligns with your inherent strengths and personality traits, you not only enhance your own effectiveness but also inspire and motivate those around you. One powerful tool for discovering your natural leadership style ... Read more
How Authenticity Builds Trust and Credibility in Leadership

How Authenticity Builds Trust and Credibility in Leadership

Authenticity stands out as a critical component of effective leadership. Authentic leaders inspire trust and credibility by being true to themselves and transparent in their interactions. This authenticity fosters a culture of confidence and mutual respect within their teams. By exploring the relationship between authenticity, trust, and credibility, we can understand why being genuine is ... Read more
Strategies for Leading in a Way That Reflects Your True Self

Strategies for Leading in a Way That Reflects Your True Self

Authentic leaders inspire trust, foster genuine connections, and create a culture where team members feel valued and understood. Leading in a way that reflects your true self means aligning your actions, decisions, and leadership style with your core values, beliefs, and personality. Here are some strategies to help you lead authentically and effectively. 1. Understand ... Read more
The Role of Emotional Intelligence in Leadership Success

The Role of Emotional Intelligence in Leadership Success

Importance of Emotional Intelligence (EQ) Emotional Intelligence (EQ) is a critical set of skills that help individuals recognize, understand, and manage their own emotions while effectively interacting with others. The core components of EQ include self-awareness, self-regulation, empathy, social skills, and motivation. These elements are not just beneficial; they are essential for anyone looking to ... Read more
Developing Emotional Intelligence for Women in Leadership

Developing Emotional Intelligence for Women in Leadership

Understanding Emotional Intelligence (EQ) Emotional Intelligence (EQ) is recognized as a crucial set of skills that determine how well we recognize and manage our own emotions, as well as how effectively we interact and empathize with others. Its components—self-awareness, self-regulation, empathy, social skills, and motivation—are essential for anyone looking to succeed in leadership roles, but ... Read more
2023 paacs women retreat 1 1 1536x1024

Becoming YOU! Women in Healthcare Leadership Retreat Project

I met the incredible Dr. Britney Grayson on another project during which we connected quickly in our shared vision to support women in healthcare leadership. Dr. Grayson has been training surgery and anesthesia residents from several African countries since 2020. Based on the results of a survey her training workgroup compiled, she invited me to build and ... Read more

Ready for fulfilling life and leadership?

Commit to growth